anki/README.contributing
Damien Elmes 30f5a82d35 drop pytype from CI checks
less useful as more type hints are added
2019-12-23 08:40:37 +10:00

109 lines
4.4 KiB
Plaintext

Contributing Code
==================
For info on contributing things other than code, such as translations, decks
and add-ons, please see http://ankisrs.net/docs/manual.html#contributing
The goal of Anki 2.1.x is to bring Anki up to date with Python 3 and Qt 5,
while maintaining compatibility with Anki 2.0.x. Some users will be stuck on
Anki 2.0 for a while due to unported add-ons or old hardware, so it's
important that 2.1 doesn't make breaking changes to the file format.
Also of consideration is that the Anki code is indirectly used by the mobile
clients, which try their best to keep as close to the Anki code as possible so
that future updates can be ported more easily. Refactoring code makes it
harder for the mobile clients to track changes, so refactoring should be
limited to times when it is necessary to address an important issue.
Before sending a pull request or a patch, please check the following to
increase your chances of the changes being accepted.
Primarily Bugfixes
-------------------
Small patches that fix a specific problem and don't affect other functionality
are likely to be merged if they meet the other requirements below. Larger
changes are less likely to be accepted for 2.1.x - if in doubt, please ask
before you begin work on them so your work does not go to waste.
Examples of changes that are unlikely to be accepted:
- Altering existing code unnecessarily. Your code may be more elegant than
what already exists, but it takes time for us to review the changes, may
harbour unnoticed bugs, and makes maintaining the mobile clients more
difficult.
- Adding code that is not used within Anki but is only for the benefit of
add-ons - such code is difficult to test and maintain.
- Adding code that addresses niche issues - they are better handled in an
add-on.
Type hints
-----------
Type hints have recently been added to parts of the codebase, mainly using
automated tools. Patches that improve the type hints are welcome, but
pragmatism is advised. Anki's codebase is old and of varying quality, and
there are parts that are difficult to type properly. Don't feel the need to
avoid 'Any' when a proper type is impractical.
When adding type signatures, please avoid refactoring the code, as this is
liable to break add-ons or introduce regressions.
When running 'make check', Anki uses mypy to typecheck the code. Mypy is fast,
but not very good at type inference, so it is mostly useful for checking code
that has type signatures. It is able to read the bundled Qt stubs, and works
across the whole Anki codebase.
You can optionally use 'make pytype' to typecheck the code with pytype. Pytype
is much slower, but it can catch errors in untyped code that mypy misses. It
is not able to check the aqt/* code, as it can't read the Qt stubs, and it is
not currently compatible with Python 3.8. It can be difficult to build on
some platforms.
The Qt stubs are not perfect, so you'll find when doing things like connecting
signals, you may have to add the following to the end of a line to silence
the spurious errors.
# type: ignore
In cases where you have two modules that reference each other, you can't simply
import the types from each module into the other one, as it can cause a cyclic
import. An example of how to work around this can be seen at
https://github.com/dae/anki/commit/ed0b3d337458d7161811547932b6476f2d4bc887
Maintaining Style
------------------
For consistency, changes should maintain the existing code style - camelCaps,
<80 column lines, succinct variable names and so on.
Tests Must Pass
----------------
Please make sure 'make check' completes successfully before submitting code.
If your change is to anki/ and not covered by the existing unit tests, please
consider adding a unit test at the same time.
Do One Thing
-------------
A patch or pull request should be the minimum necessary to address one issue.
Please don't make a pull request for a bunch of unrelated changes, as they are
difficult to review and will be rejected - split them up into separate
requests instead.
License
-------
As mentioned in the LICENSE file, we are only able to accept non-trivial
patches or pull requests from people who have sent us a private message
indicating that they license their changes under the BSD license.
Add-ons
========
If you'd like to make more extensive changes, please consider writing an
add-on instead, as add-ons have none of these restrictions and can implement
whatever functionality in whatever style you wish.